[odf-discuss] A bit more detailed explanation of the AFNORposition

[marbux]

On 9/25/07, Daniel Carrera <daniel.carrera at zmsl.com> wrote:
>
> Thanks Max. Personally I'm tired of hearing this rant from Marbux.
> Marbux's claims have been throughly debunked by a lot of people who
> actually know ODF and actually have ODF implementations in the market.
> At some point one starts to get tired of debunking the exact same claims
> over and over.


You're being silly again Daniel. My claims under discussion have never been
"debunked." Like you, a lot of people have called me names, but no one has
debunked what I've been saying about ODF and interop. Like you, they attack
the messenger rather than dealing with the technical issues. I am talking
about far more than just the lists  amendment. And my lists use case is
still waiting for anyone who claims to have "debunked" me to solve. Just
like my business process and migration use cases. Some "debunking."

And those folks with implementations you choose to believe (all one of them)
without doing your homework are not people who have even attempted high
fidelity round trip interop with MS Office. They lack the necessary
expertise. But our proof of concept MS plug-in is still there for anyone to
download and test.

Are you denying that ODF lacks interoperability conformance requirements
other than validation? ISO/IEC JTC 1 Directives require:

Standards designed to facilitate interoperability need to specify clearly
> > and unambiguously the conformity requirements that are essential to achieve
> > the interoperability.
> >
>
And that is a mandatory requirement. So show me where those interop
conformance requirements are, Daniel. Show me where the ODF interop
framework is.

I said it before and I'll say it again, Daniel. You're a troll. You have
nothing but ad hominem attacks and other logical fallacies in your gun. Your
latest post is just further proof.


BUCK "MARBUX" MARTIN
  Director of Legal Affairs
  OpenDocument Foundation
  Contact:
<http://www.opendocumentfoundation.us/contact.htm>
-- Universal Interop Now!
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.opendocumentfellowship.com/pipermail/odf-discuss/attachments/20070925/0fc9ac4d/attachment-0001.htm